Commercial Insurance
Company Name Phone Number
Alliance of Nonprofits for Insurance Call the Agency
AmTrust (888) 239-3909
AXIS Capital Call the Agency
Berkeley Mid-Atlantic Group (800) 283-1153
Charity First (888) 875-5231
Chesapeake Employer Insurance Company (888) 410-1400
CNA (877) 262-2727
Chubb (800) 252-4670
Workers’ Compensation Claims – (800) 699-9916
Church Mutual Call the Agency
Donegal Mutual (800) 877-9006
First Comp (888) 611-7467
Foremost (800) 527-3907
Great American Insurance Company (800) 545-4269
Hartford (800) 327-3636
Hartford Mutual (800) 638-3669
Liberty Mutual (800) 225-2467
Markel (800) 362-7535
Medical Mutual (800) 382-5729
Peninsula (800) 492-1205
Philadelphia Insurance (800) 765-9749
Progressive (800) 776-4737
Selective (866) 455-9969
Glass Claims (800) 638-8961
Workers’ Compensation Claims (800) 305-0483
St. Paul Travelers (800) 238-6225
Zurich (800) 239-4781
Zurich North America (877) 928-4531
   

Personal Insurance
Company Name Phone Number
ASI/American Strategic Insurance/Progressive (866) 274-5677
Chubb/ACE (800) 252-4670
Donegal Mutual (800) 877-9006
Foremost (800) 527-3907
Hartford (800) 423-0033
Kemper (Unitrin/Kemper) (888) 252-2799
Met Life (800) 854-8888
Peninsula (800) 492-1205
Penn National (800) 766-2245
Progressive (800) 925-2886
(800) 888-7764
Roadside Service (888) 776-2778
SAFECO (800) 332-3226
Travelers (800) 252-4633